Cooking fish at home doesn’t have to feel intimidating. With the right seasoning for fish, even simple fillets can taste restaurant-quality—fresh, balanced, and full of flavor.
At NC Seafood, we focus on flavor combinations that complement—not compete with—our fresh Calabash-style seafood. That starts with seasoning the flour and batter that give Calabash fish its signature bite, then finishing each dish with lemon, house sauces, or simple pairings that enrich the natural fish flavor without masking it.
Join our seafood restaurant team as we explore the best seasoning for fish, based on different fish types and cooking methods, so you can build the right flavor profile whether you’re baking, pan-frying, or grilling at home.
Table of Contents
What Seasonings Go Well With Fish?
Fish is naturally mild, so it acts like a blank canvas. With the right herbs and spices to flavor fish, you can push flavor in any direction: citrusy, smoky, peppery, buttery, or bold with heat.
To be the best seasoning for fish, your spice blend will usually include:
- Salt
- Pepper
- Paprika
- Garlic powder
- Celery salt
- Dried parsley
- Lemon
- Cayenne pepper (for a little kick)
This combo shows up over and over in great seafood dishes because it works. It adds flavor without turning your dish into a meal more focused on over-seasoning than complementing the natural flavor of the fish meat.
Fish Seasoning & Cooking Method Guide
| Fish Type | Best Seasoning Style | Recommended Spices & Herbs | Best Cooking Method | Why It Works |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Salmon | Herb + Citrus | Dill, lemon zest, garlic, paprika, cardamom | Baking, Grilling | Balances salmon’s natural richness without masking it |
| White Fish (Cod, Haddock, Tilapia) | Light + Fresh | Ginger, lemongrass, parsley, paprika, red pepper flake | Baking, Pan Frying | Enhances mild fish without overpowering the flavor |
| Swordfish | Bold + Herbal | Peri peri, garlic, rosemary, parsley, paprika | Grilling | Matches the steak-like texture with stronger spices |
| Tuna | Herb + Pepper | Oregano, dill, parsley, sesame seeds, ginger | Quick Searing | Keeps flavors clean and sharp for rare or medium-rare tuna |
| Fried Fish (Calabash-Style) | Classic Seafood | Paprika, garlic powder, celery salt, black pepper | Pan Frying | Creates NC Seafood’s signature seasoned batter flavor |
| Grilled Fish (Any Type) | Smoky + Spicy | Smoked paprika, cayenne, celery salt, lemon pepper | Grilling | Stands up to high heat and char flavor |
The Best Seasoning for Fish: A Quick Homemade Recipe
A good homemade fish seasoning saves time, cuts down on measuring, and makes your seafood dishes taste consistent every single time. It’s the kind of shortcut that doesn’t feel like a shortcut—because you’re still using real spices, just in a smarter format.
This homemade fish seasoning is balanced, versatile, and works for a variety of fish, including salmon, shrimp, and white fish like sea bass, cod, haddock, flounder, tilapia, and halibut.
In a small bowl, mix:
- 2 tbsp paprika
- 1 tbsp garlic powder
- 1 tbsp celery salt
- 1 tbsp dried parsley
- 1 tsp smoked paprika
- 1 tsp cayenne pepper
- 1 tsp black pepper
- ½ tsp ground ginger
- ½ tsp oregano
This fish seasoning mix hits the sweet spot, as all the spices mix into a savory, lightly smoky, and not too salty flavor profile.
How to Store Your Homemade Fish Seasoning
Instead of measuring 12 spices every time you bake fish, you can mix a big batch once, store it in an airtight container, and use it anytime you want quick flavor for the best-tasting fish at home. For the best shelf life, keep your seasoning mix tightly sealed in a cool, dry cabinet, away from heat and sunlight, so the spices stay fresh and aromatic for months.
The Best Seasoning for Salmon
Salmon has natural richness, so it can handle stronger spice blends. But it still tastes best when the seasoning supports that buttery flavor the fish is known for.
Dill
+
Dill is delicate, fresh, and honestly made for salmon. It adds flavor without overpowering the dish.
How to use it:
- Sprinkle dried dill into your fish seasoning before baking
- Finish seasoned fish with fresh dill and lemon after cooking
- Stir dill into butter for a quick topping
Lemon Zest
+
Lemon keeps salmon tasting clean, not heavy. It’s especially useful if you bake salmon.
Try:
- Lemon zest with butter and garlic powder
- Lemon zest with our homemade seasoning and a light coat of oil
Cardamom Spice Blend
+
Cardamom brings a warm, slightly sweet edge that plays well with salmon’s natural richness.
An easy idea is to:
- Rub salmon with a spice mix using paprika, salt, cardamom, and cayenne
- Bake until flaky, then finish with lemon
The Best Seasoning for White Fish
White fish is mild and delicate—sea bass, cod, haddock, and tilapia are common examples. This is where you want to add flavor while keeping the profile simple and clean.
Ginger and Lemongrass
+
This combo brings brightness and a light “restaurant-style” flavor.
Quick approach:
- Add ground ginger to your homemade fish seasoning
- Finish with lemon (or lime) right before serving fish
Parsley, Paprika, and Red Pepper Flake Blend
+
If you want that “classic seafood flavor,” this is the best choice for delicate, white flaky fish.
Why it works:
- Paprika adds warmth
- Parsley adds freshness
- Pepper adds bite
Use smoked paprika here if you’re baking.
Cajun Spice Blend
+
Cajun blends usually include paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, black pepper, celery salt, oregano, and cayenne—so it’s basically built to be one of the best fish seasoning options for home chefs.
Best ways to use Cajun seasoning:
- As a dry rub before pan frying
- Sprinkled on fish before baking
- Mixed into butter as a seafood dipping sauce
The Best Seasoning for Swordfish
Swordfish has a firm, steak-like texture. It holds up to strong seasoning and high-heat cooking.
Peri Peri Blend
+
Peri peri gives you citrus, chili heat, and garlic. It’s bold, but when used right, it’s absolutely delicious.
Great uses:
- Peri peri dry rub before grilling fish
- Peri peri seasoning mix stirred into butter for basting
Garlic, Rosemary, and Parsley Blend
+
This is a more traditional blend of seasonings for fish. The herbs bring freshness; garlic brings punch.
Try combining:
- Garlic powder
- Dried parsley
- Paprika
- Salt
- Pepper
Then bake or grill the fish meat.
The Best Seasoning for Tuna
Tuna works well with herbal or pepper-forward blends, especially when seared.
Mediterranean Herb Blend
+
Think oregano, dill, parsley, and lemon. It’s clean, not heavy.
How to use it:
- Toss herbs with seasoning and oil
- Rub onto tuna
- Quick sear without overcooking
Toasted Sesame Seeds
+
Sesame seeds add crunch and a nutty finish to tuna, especially great for searing the outside of the fish with a raw center. You can also elevate the flavor by adding ginger to the sesame for a more layered taste.
Cooking Methods That Make Fish Seasonings Taste Better
Seasoning is only half the job. Cooking is where real flavor comes through for fish dishes.
Baking Fish
Baking is great for salmon and white fish.
Tips:
- Bake fish at 375–425°F, depending on thickness
- Butter helps keep lean fish moist
- Sprinkle extra seasoning halfway through for deeper flavor
Pan Frying Fish
Pan frying works well when you want a little crust on the flesh or a crispy skin exterior.
Tips:
- Pat fish dry
- Use butter or oil
- Don’t move the fish too soon
This is where a fish seasoned with paprika and pepper really shines.
Grilling Fish
Grilled fish needs a slightly stronger spice mix.
Use:
- Smoked paprika
- Cayenne
- Celery salt
- A lemon pepper blend
The Best Seasoning for Fish FAQs
What are the 4 basic seasonings for fish?
+
Salt, black pepper, garlic powder, and paprika.
What to put on fish to make it taste better?
+
Dry the fish first, coat lightly with olive oil or butter, season evenly with your spice and herb blend, then finish with lemon after cooking.
Can I just use Old Bay seasoning for my fish?
+
Yes—Old Bay is a solid all-in-one option, especially for shrimp and fried or baked fish. Just keep in mind it’s already fairly salty and bold, so use a lighter hand at first. If you are a seafood lover, having it available as a pantry staple ingredient can allow you to create your own Old Bay recipe ideas to enhance fish dishes.
At what stage of cooking should I season my fish with a spice blend?
+
Season your fish right before cooking for the best flavor and texture. Pat the fish dry first, then apply your spice blend so it sticks evenly.
What flavor profiles most complement a wide variety of fish?
+
The most versatile flavor profiles are citrus-forward and herb-based blends with mild heat. Think lemon, garlic powder, paprika, dill, parsley, and black pepper—ingredients that add flavor while letting the fish still taste fresh.
Contact NC Seafood Today for Perfectly Seasoned Fish in Raleigh
Homemade fish seasoning is fun—and it’s a great way to level up your cooking. But sometimes you just want someone else to handle dinner for a change. If you’re craving fresh seafood and seasoned fish that’s cooked the way it should be, visit NC Seafood at the Raleigh State Farmers Market. You can also place an order online to plan ahead or order from our take-out menu.
If you enjoy recipes or information about seafood and fish in general, sign up for our monthly e-newsletter. Sent once a month, we share what’s happening around Raleigh, what’s in season, and a roundup of new seafood recipe ideas from our blog.